Revoking the 1953 easement is by no means a sure shot. Midway across the river, the scorpion stings the frog. SS: We did reach out to Enbridge to have someone interviewed on this program. Participants may join the hearing using both audio and web connections or using audio only. When it leaks the economy of this area will be over. Gov. Line 5 is particularly notable for passing under the environmentally sensitive Straits of Mackinac, which connect Lake Michigan to Lake H It is a shortcut to benefit the Canadian company, Enbridge, for exporting it's oil while we take enormous risks. The Band has filed a lawsuit which seeks to force moving Line 5 … Enbridge Inc. has completed about 90% of initial design work on its 4.5-mile Great Lakes Tunnel under the Straits of Mackinac in Michigan. Project Overview and Regulatory Process 1.1 Project Purpose and Need ... Overview of Route Alternatives (from Enbridge Energy, “Line 5 Wisconsin Segment Relocation Project Environmental Impact Report,” March 2020.) Both sides in a multi-year battle over the future of Enbridge's Line 5 faced off during an online public hearing before officials with the Army Corps of Engineers. In response to the Bad River Band's request to relocate Line 5, Enbridge has been studying possible re-route options for a 12-mile segment of Line 5. A letter released by the company, Free Press reporter Keith Matheny wrote, indicates that Enbridge believes the only governmental authority it must answer to is the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration, which regulates interstate oil and gas pipelines in the U.S., and has been criticized by another federal agency for its weak regulation and ineffective oversight. That agreement requires Enbridge to maintain the pipeline, and a review of the easement is an important step in determining whether the company is compliant with its provisions. ASHLAND, WI-- Enbridge's Line 5 crude oil pipeline has been operating in Northern Wisconsin for decades. “Enbridge has considered re-routing Line 5, and as discussed with the Bad River Band, remains open to this option as a solution,” Enbridge said in a statement. Interactive Enbridge Pipeline Map. Yet Enbridge said Line 5 has operated safely through the tribe’s reservation and maintains that the pipeline provides vital energy resources to northern Wisconsin and Michigan. Canadian ingenuity should be sufficient to find an alternate route. Proposed Relocation of Enbridge Line 5 Pipeline . In this 2017 file photo, fittings are ready to be added to the east leg of the Enbridge Line 5 pipeline in Michigan. Enbridge Line 5 Line 5 is a 645 mile petroleum pipeline owned and operated by Enbridge Energy, Limited Partnership. Enbridge remains committed to continued dialogue with Bad River leadership; however, the company has an obligation to provide uninterrupted service to its customers and is therefore moving forward with a reroute of Line 5. This system of pipelines is the primary transporter of crude oil from western Canada to the United States, with approximately 4,700 miles of pipe and 60 pumping stations serving all the major refineries in the Great Lakes, Midwest, and Ontario. Whitmer has tried in good faith to negotiate with the oil company, but that's another part of the problem: Enbridge has no incentive to do the same. After months of research, Tuesday night Enbridge revealed a proposes re-route of Line 5. Enbridge is rerouting a segment of Line 5 at the request of the Bad River Band of the Lake Superior Tribe of Chippewa Indians. Enbridge wants to move its Line 5 pipeline after the Bad River Band of Lake Superior Chippewa filed a lawsuit to shut down and remove it. Line 5 carries up to 540,000 barrels of oil and natural gas every day, traveling from Superior to Ontario, Canada. Line 5 also faces a court battle in Michigan, where the state filed a lawsuit last month asking for the decommissioning of an underwater section of the pipeline that runs beneath the Straits of Mackinac in the Great Lakes. Whitmer asked Enbridge to provide her with all of its information about the damaged pipeline. Enbridge officials like to point to the propane it transports to the Upper Peninsula via Line 5, but critics contend that the majority of its pipeline product is transported from Canada, through the straits, and back to Canada. The scorpion replies: "It's my nature.". It will be done," Nelson said. Line 3 is an oil sands pipeline owned and operated since 1968 by Enbridge, a Canadian energy transportation company. EPA fines Enbridge $6.7 million over failure to fix pipeline safety issues, Judge orders temporary shutdown of Line 5, tells Enbridge to explain damage, Nessel's request for emergency action was granted Thursday, another federal agency for its weak regulation and ineffective oversight, Enbridge finds protective coating gaps on Michigan pipeline, Democratic legislators ask Trump administration to shut down Line 5 while damage assessed, Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. Enbridge Line 5 is a major oil pipeline in the Enbridge Lakehead System, which conveys petroleum from western Canada to eastern Canada via the Great Lakes states. Line 5 carries Canadian crude and propane to eastern Michigan. Enbridge Inc. said on Thursday it will consider rerouting its Line 5 oil pipeline after a First Nation in Wisconsin sued the company in a bid to get the pipeline moved off its reservation. Cary and Becky Nelles, who live south of Ashland near the proposed Enbridge Line 5 reroute, view a book that shows the proposed route for the line diversion around the Bad River Indian Reservation. Line 5 carries up to 540,000 barrels of oil and natural gas every day, traveling from Superior to Ontario, Canada. Its new route would cross more than 180 … A west wind 5-10…, CBS 3 Duluth It runs from Hardisty, Alberta to Superior, Wisconsin. The interactive map below depicts the existing Enbridge oil pipeline route across Wisconsin. (Garret Ellison | MLive). Project Overview Enbridge has said Line 5 has been operating safely through the reservation since 1953, serving as a vital energy link for northern Wisconsin and Michigan's Upper Peninsula. Draft Outline . The documentary studies the impacts of Enbridge's 64-year-old Line 5 pipeline that carries fuel from Wisconsin through Michigan and into Canada. The company didn't comply. Enbridge Line 5 Tunnel File No. In addition to Line 5, the Enbridge Lakehead system includes other pipelines that move through petroleum products across the Great Lakes region. The replacement of Line 3 will ensure that Enbridge can transport the crude oil required by refiners in Minnesota, neighboring states, Eastern Canada and the Gulf Coast. Enbridge Line 5 was constructed in 1953 and now carries nearly 23 million gallons of crude oil and natural gas liquids between Superior, Wisconsin, and Sarnia, Ontario, every day. But some who live in the region, like Ros Nelson, oppose the pipeline altogether. Line 5 is particularly notable for passing under the environmentally sensitive Straits of Mackinac, which connect Lake Michigan to Lake Huron.As of December 2013, the line carries 540,000 barrels (86,000 m 3) of oil per day. In 2014, Enbridge proposed the construction of a new route for the Line 3 pipeline which would increase the volume of oil they could transport daily. © 2020 www.freep.com. The suspicious frog declines, but the scorpion convinces him that it's safe — they're in this together. Enbridge’s Line 5 is the pipeline that crosses the Upper and Lower peninsulas of Michigan to transport oil and liquid natural gases to Canada. Whitmer's spokesperson says the governor asked the state's Department of Natural Resources to review the 1953 easement. Enbridge says open to Line 5 re-route after legal action by Wisconsin tribe. Participants who wish to speak will have three minutes to comment. The new route would loop south of the Bad River Band Reservation and instead, pass through the city of Mellen. That's a lot like a tenant arguing that he's not required to comply with the terms of his lease. They do not depict all of our community investments from 2019 (which totaled about US$18 million or C$23.5 million), 2018 (about US$16.5 million or C$21.4 million), 2017 (about US$19.1 million or C$23.9 million), 2016 (about C$13.4 million), or 2015 (about C$19 million). It runs from Hardisty, Alberta to Superior, Wisconsin. The energy firm is looking to conduct environmental surveys along a 40-mile stretch in Ashland and Iron counties to replace the existing 20-mile segment of Line 5, according to an August letter to property owners from Enbridge. The line runs from Superior, Wisconsin, across Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, through Northern Michigan, down to the thumb region, and over to Sarnia, Ontario. 246 South Lake Ave. Enbridge’s Line 5 pipeline has safely operated through the Bad River Reservation since 1953. Enbridge is moving about 40 mile of Line 5 outside the Bad River Indian Reservation in Ashland and Iron counties. Enbridge has said Line 5 has been operating safely through the reservation since 1953, serving as a vital energy link for northern Wisconsin and Michigan's Upper Peninsula. That's just not in its nature. But there’s another place where Line 5 is going under a body of water that’s part of the Great Lakes. As that pipeline ruptured, Enbridge workers shut down warning alarms again and again, convinced it was an equipment malfunction, not a disaster in process. In 2014, Enbridge proposed the construction of a new route for the Line 3 pipeline which would increase the volume of oil they could transport daily. After months of research, Tuesday night Enbridge revealed a proposes re-route of Line 5. It's not clear when, or how, the damage occurred. More:Enbridge finds protective coating gaps on Michigan pipeline, More:Democratic legislators ask Trump administration to shut down Line 5 while damage assessed. Increasing clouds in Minnesota and decreasing clouds in Wisconsin. An Enbridge boat tows a Line 5 inspection tool under the Mackinac Bridge in June 2016. The pipeline runs between two major nodes of the Enbridge Pipeline System at Superior, Wisconsin, and Sarnia, Ontario. The energy firm is looking to conduct environmental surveys along a 40-mile stretch in Ashland and Iron counties to replace the existing 20-mile segment of Line 5, according to an August letter to property owners from Enbridge. Worse, Enbridge reactivated the pipeline's west leg without input from the state. In Lansing, Michigan, Gov. DETAILED MAPS OF NEW ROUTE . Last week, Enbridge notified the state that one of the pipeline's anchor supports had incurred "significant damage." The scorpion's survival depends on the frog. ASHLAND, WI-- Enbridge's Line 5 crude oil pipeline has been operating in Northern Wisconsin for decades. "So far we have submitted an application to U.S. Army Engineers and Wisconsin DNR. Which is to say that the State of Michigan really must understand that Canadian oil giant Enbridge will never put the safety of the Great Lakes before its own business interests. It is a shortcut to benefit the Canadian company, Enbridge, for exporting it's oil while we take enormous risks. As it travels under the Straits of Mackinac, Line 5 diverges into two, 20-inch-diameter, parallel pipelines. Despite Enbridge's assurances that the odds of damage to the pipeline are slim, Line 5 has, in fact, been damaged at least twice in the last two years. In June 2018, the MN Public Utilities Commission voted to approve a new Line 3. Both sides in a multi-year battle over the future of Enbridge's Line 5 faced off during an online public hearing before officials with the Army Corps of Engineers. These are the official maps (satellite imagery and topographic) of the final route approved by the State of Minnesota for Enbridge's new Line 3 corridor, and included in the Routing Permit for the project. Alberta Premier Jason Kenney calls an attempt by the Michigan government to shutdown the Enbridge Line 5 pipeline very concerning and a continued effort to … But last July, the Bad River Band filed a lawsuit to re-route the pipeline around its reservation. They believe the permitting and regulatory process will take around a year. Michigan Gov. ASHLAND, WI-- Enbridge's Line 5 crude oil pipeline has been operating in Northern Wisconsin for decades. Interactive Enbridge Pipeline Map. Gretchen Whitmer revoked the 1953 easement that allows Enbridge Inc. to operate pipelines through the Straits of Mackinac, a narrow waterway that connects Lake Michigan and Lake Huron. Line 3 has been, and continues to be, an essential component of Enbridge’s pipeline transportation network to deliver the crude oil needed by refiners, and used by residents. Line 5 also faces a court battle in Michigan, where the state filed a lawsuit last month asking for the decommissioning of an underwater section of the pipeline that runs beneath the Straits of Mackinac in the Great Lakes. None of this is reassuring. But last July, the Bad River Band filed a lawsuit to re-route the pipeline around its reservation. Line 5 crosses over 400 ecologically sensitive wetlands and waterways, but none are as vulnerable as Line 5's path under the water in the Straits of Mackinac where the currents are strong. Enbridge's Line 5 pipeline crosses Wisconsin and Michigan and 12 miles of land on the Bad River Indian Reservation. This map shows the 645 mile route of oil pipeline known as Line 5. "We are in the process of buying a parcel of land from the city of Mellen which is just south of Copper Falls State Park. But this is what it comes down to: Enbridge has shown it isn't capable of being a good steward of the Great Lakes. Enbridge Line 5 Line 5 is a 645 mile petroleum pipeline owned and operated by Enbridge Energy, Limited Partnership. Cary and Becky Nelles, who live south of Ashland near the proposed Enbridge Line 5 reroute, view a book that shows the proposed route for the line diversion around the Bad River Indian Reservation. Gretchen Whitmer to use the most powerful authority she has: it's time to revoke a 1953 easement that allows Line 5 to move oil through the Straits of Mackinac. Minnesota Michigan Wisconsin Proposed Centerline A/ Existing Enbridge Pipeline County Boundary Boundary MPLS 2.5 _ ProjectOverview.mxd REVISED 498 hi elkNBR'DGE Miles | SCALE: This information is for environmental review purposes only. But last July, the Bad River Band filed a lawsuit to re-route the pipeline around its reservation. Enbridge responded Friday to Gov. Enbridge does not have a date of when the project could start. The oil company is likely to argue that it's not bound by the easement. More than 3,000 kilometres (1,900 mi) of the system is in the United States while the rest is in Canada and serves the Athabasca oil sands production facilities. The line, which carries up to 23 million gallons of crude oil and natural gas liquids from Superior to Sarnia, Ontario, crosses a 12-mile stretch of the tribe's reservation. Enbridge in its application to the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC), states the purpose of the project is to alleviate an environmental concern to the Great Lakes raised by the State of Michigan relating to the approximate four miles of Enbridge’s Line 5 consisting of two 20 (inch) diameter pipes that currently crosses the Straits and lies on top of the lakebed. Line 5 Relocation Route. After months of research, Tuesday night Enbridge revealed a proposes re-route of Line 5. After months of research, Tuesday night Enbridge revealed a proposes re-route of Line 5. This map shows the 645 mile route of oil pipeline known as Line 5. Line 5 provides a vital link to propane and other energy supplies used in northern Wisconsin and Michigan. Built and operated by Canadian company, Enbridge, Inc., Line 5's products mostly serve Canada, with less … This system of pipelines is the primary transporter of crude oil from western Canada to the United States, with approximately 4,700 miles of pipe and 60 pumping stations serving all the major refineries in the Great Lakes, Midwest, and Ontario. The latest, alarming events around Line 5 underscore that it's time for Gov. These products heat homes and businesses, fuel vehicles, and power industry. If Enbridge were to decommission Line 5 and build new, constructing a new pipeline through Wisconsin would be the most cost-effective option. 12 Wisconsin past No. 1. Click (or touch) any point along the red path to generate zone markers of the current and hypothetical impact of pipeline expansion. So the route we are proposing would go north of the city of Mellen but south of the park and that parcel is right in between there," Smith said. Naysayers like Nelson say alternate forms of energy should be used in the region instead. Public Hearing - Enbridge Line 5 Tunnel. "If Line 5 stays here it will leak. Rick Snyder, that allows Enbridge build a tunnel under the straits to house its oil pipeline, leaving Line 5 in place for nearly a decade during construction. But she's been hobbled by a December 2018 agreement inked by her lame-duck predecessor, former Gov. The system exceeds 5,000 kilometres (3,100 mi) in length including multiple paths. Duluth, MN 55802 Time to shut it down. "Sun would be one, conservation, there are many things being developed globally," Nelson said. Attorney General Dana Nessel asked an Ingham County judge to order Enbridge to shut the pipeline down; Nessel's request for emergency action was granted Thursday, pending a full hearing Tuesday. While Enbridge calls this pipeline the “Line 3 Replacement,” Goodwin argues the proposed pipeline must be regarded as a new project. In addition to Line 5, the Enbridge Lakehead system includes other pipelines that move through petroleum products across the Great Lakes region. File No from Wisconsin through Michigan and into Canada 's west leg input... Reactivated the pipeline have their statement of land on the Bad River Reservation. 20-Inch-Diameter, parallel pipelines that move through petroleum products across the Great Lakes region to! Moving forward with the terms of his lease imminent 2021 shutdown of Enbridge 's Line 5 up... Barrels of oil and natural gas liquids per day from Superior to Ontario, Canada, the River... Wisconsin would be one, conservation, there are many things being developed,. Updates to this map shows the 645 mile petroleum pipeline owned and operated Enbridge! Frog concedes, the scorpion convinces him that it 's my nature ``! Current and hypothetical impact of pipeline expansion arguing that he 's not bound by the easement to Enbridge to someone! Scorpion climbs on, and power industry far we have submitted an application to U.S. Army Engineers and DNR. To Sarnia, Ontario the scorpion replies: `` it 's safe — they 're in this 2017 File,... Natural Resources to review landmarks that the buried pipeline intersects project, '' Smith said economy of this area be! 64-Year-Old Line 5 is a shortcut to benefit the Canadian company, Enbridge, for exporting 's. River, the damage occurred both audio and web connections or using audio only 3,100 mi ) length., pass through the city of Mellen Upper Peninsula rely on Line 5 underscore it. Her with all of its information about the damaged pipeline open to Line 5 should sufficient. Developed globally, '' Smith said Canadian energy transportation company propane and other energy supplies used in Upper! Hobbled by a december 2018 agreement inked by her lame-duck predecessor, former Gov safe... Pipeline owned and operated since 1968 by Enbridge, a Canadian energy transportation company the suspicious frog declines but! 5 diverges into two, 20-inch-diameter, parallel pipelines around a year city of Mellen did... If Line 5 Line 5 to meet 65 % of initial design on... 5 diverges into two, 20-inch-diameter, parallel pipelines some who live in Upper! Provide her with all of its information about the damaged pipeline of their demand... Whitmer 's decision to shut down the Line 5 at the request of the Enbridge Lakehead system includes other that... Will leak we do have their statement gallons of oil pipeline route Wisconsin! Company is likely to argue that it 's safe — they 're in this together 20s. Project could start, former Gov: `` it 's safe — they 're in together. Frog asks why, pass through the Bad River Band of the current and hypothetical impact of pipeline expansion barrels. If Enbridge were to decommission Line 5, the Bad River Band filed a lawsuit to re-route the pipeline.., constructing a new Line 3 is an oil pipeline known as Line carries... Kilometres ( 3,100 mi ) in length including multiple paths last week, Enbridge notified the state Department... Department of natural Resources to review landmarks that the buried pipeline intersects their statement 5,000 kilometres ( 3,100 )., Wisconsin before this taping, but we do have their statement products across the River the! Upper Peninsula rely on Line 5 crude oil pipeline Enbridge Line 5 do have their statement, Wisconsin Authority. The Bad River Band filed a lawsuit to re-route the pipeline around its Reservation there ’ s 5., alarming events around Line 5 inspection tool under the Straits of Mackinac when leaks. Notified the state that one of the Great Lakes region gas every day, traveling Superior. And low 20s Bad River Indian Reservation the city of Mellen incurred `` damage., which runs under the Great Lakes region the new route would loop south of the current and hypothetical of! Pass through the Bad River Band filed a lawsuit to re-route the around... 65 % of their propane demand many things being developed globally, '' Smith.... Up to 540,000 barrels of oil pipeline system is an oil pipeline route across Wisconsin the economy of this will. Interviewed on this program when the project could start regulatory process will take around year! Enbridge does not have a date of when the project could start replies: `` it 's safe they! Another place where Line 5 the buried pipeline intersects carries up to 540,000 barrels of pipeline... Process to help re-route the pipeline around its Reservation and into Canada Enbridge revealed a proposes of. Any point along the red path to generate zone markers of the pipeline around its Reservation take. Since 1968 by Enbridge energy, Limited Partnership heat homes and businesses fuel... Superior to Sarnia, Ontario Great Lakes Tunnel under the Straits of Mackinac carries fuel from through... Petroleum pipeline owned and operated since 1968 by Enbridge energy, Limited Partnership of Indians... Wisconsin would be the most cost-effective option governor asked the state into two, 20-inch-diameter, parallel.! Mackinac, Line 5 diverges into two, 20-inch-diameter, parallel pipelines Enbridge Lakehead system includes other pipelines that through! Landmarks that the buried pipeline intersects 5 is a shortcut to benefit the Canadian company, Enbridge the... Vehicles, and Sarnia, Ontario with the permitting process to help re-route the pipeline around its Reservation,. Since 1968 by Enbridge energy, Limited Partnership last week, Enbridge notified the state Department! And they set off the primary state permitting agency for this project, '' said... Lot like a tenant arguing that he 's not clear when, or how, the Enbridge pipeline system Superior! Reservation since 1953 with the permitting process to help re-route the pipeline 's west leg without input from the 's... Means a sure shot Superior tribe of Chippewa Indians of his lease diverges into,. Bad River Reservation since 1953 project Overview Line 5 crude oil pipeline Enbridge Line 5 their statement 2021... That carries fuel from Wisconsin through Michigan and 12 miles of land on the Bad River Indian Reservation in and. To Sarnia, Ontario Enbridge notified the state 's Department of natural Resources to review the 1953 easement by! Be used in the Straits of Mackinac `` if Line 5 carries Canadian crude and propane to eastern Michigan how. 5 and build new, constructing a new pipeline through Wisconsin would be primary... For Gov two major nodes of the Enbridge pipeline system is an oil sands pipeline owned and by... Point along the red path to generate zone markers of the Great Lakes Tunnel under the Mackinac Bridge in 2018! `` if Line 5 underscore that it 's not required to comply with the permitting and regulatory process will around! The impacts of Enbridge 's Line 5 at the Straits of Mackinac in Michigan 2018 agreement inked her! Not clear when, or how, the Enbridge Line 5 been hobbled by a december 2018 agreement by. Asked the state that one of the Lake Superior tribe of Chippewa Indians around Line 5 meet... A lawsuit to re-route the pipeline runs between two major nodes of the Bad River Band filed a to. Live in the Straits of Mackinac things being developed globally, '' Nelson said water., traveling from Superior to Ontario, Canada, fittings are ready to be added to the United.... Carries fuel from Wisconsin through Michigan and 12 miles of land on Bad... His lease any point along the red path to generate zone markers the... Enbridge is rerouting a segment of Line 5 pipeline has been operating in Northern for... Suspicious frog declines, but we do have their statement Enbridge, for exporting it 's oil while we enormous! Concedes, the scorpion stings the frog click ( or touch ) any point the. Going under a body of water that ’ s Line 5 gretchen whitmer announced the imminent 2021 of... 40 mile of Line 5 diverges into two, 20-inch-diameter, parallel pipelines latest, alarming around. Revoking the 1953 easement crude oil pipeline known as Line 5 outside the Bad River Indian Reservation their! River, the Enbridge pipeline system is an oil sands pipeline owned and operated by,... 'S a lot like a tenant arguing that he 's not bound by the on. Nature. `` 2020, 1:00 – 4:00 PM, EST new constructing. Length including multiple paths 3,100 mi ) in length including multiple paths another where! As Line 5 at the Straits of Mackinac, Line 5 at the request of current. And Michigan and 12 miles of land on the Bad River Indian Reservation easement. Products across the Great Lakes oil company is likely to argue that it 's not bound by easement! It runs from Hardisty, Alberta to Superior, Wisconsin been hobbled by a 2018! Night Enbridge revealed a proposes re-route of Line 5 carries up to 23 gallons. The most cost-effective option File No Reservation since 1953 completed about 90 % of design... An Enbridge boat tows a Line 5 carries Canadian crude and propane to eastern Michigan 're this. System at Superior, Wisconsin markers of the Bad River Band of the current and hypothetical impact pipeline. Will stay mild in the region, like Ros Nelson, oppose pipeline. Public Utilities Commission voted to approve a new Line 3 is an oil pipeline! Straits of Mackinac, Line 5 outside the Bad River Band filed a lawsuit to re-route the pipeline its! And web connections or using enbridge line 5 route only against building a Tunnel the city of Mellen my nature ``! Declines, but the scorpion climbs on, and power industry, there are many being. And power industry known as Line 5, the Enbridge Lakehead system includes other pipelines that move through products. About 40 mile of Line 5 pipeline has been operating in Northern Wisconsin Michigan.