They only do 1 merino wool shirt (and a long sleeve version). You should check out Son of A Tailor. Another well-deserved brand name for a line of well-engineered Merino socks that just don’t quit. What's your experience with them and recommendation? Feel free to share your favourite bags and your packing lists. But being human, this seem boring, and I'm wondering if there is … The Smartwool tee with the nylon core and the Icebreaker with the TENCEL seem very intriguing. My Smartwool 150 is a little itchy. Got it in XL tall and love it. Icebreaker vs Smartwool vs Minus33 is a common riddle for beginners. Smartwool vs. Icebreaker vs. Wooly seems to be the best choices as far as I can tell, but which one? The absol6 DISRESPECT for leaving out darn tough.. It is a little short for me being 6'5 though. The Versa is what I’d call mid-weight, and it is not close fitting enough for me, as I’m a thin-waisted buck fifty. I'm interested in reddit prefers. Neither are hurting for cash and both want to sell. My favorite shirt. **Reminder:** Please use the search function before making a request. Iemand ervaring met beide merken? I do hate the woolly tag they sew on the chest though but you can cut that off. Don't know how you could survive without light weight, loose fitting cotton. Re: the woolly v neck - did you get the men’s or woman’s for your wife? Thanks! A Woolly v neck & henley as a mid layer retains a good amount of warmth. Full transparency. Smartwool are great at accessories – like the legendary PhD socks, or the neat neck gaiters made of 100% merino wool goodness. The fit is good, the material is soft and comfortable, and the construction is quality. What the heck is merino wool anyway? For example, Smartwool 150 would mean any product from Smartwool that weighs 150 grams. At first, it may seem like overkill, but it also maintains its elasticity over time better than most models we have ever tested after over a year of use. icebreaker has some mixed stuff. The waistband is burly. I had them in mind for work-appropriate wear but not casual. Wool and prince makes a merino polo also. If they are close in price I'd choose First Lite. Right now Sierra Trading Post has some sales on their wool clothing, but I"m trying to figure out which brand to go with. The Icebreaker men's range from x-small to xxx-large, but the Smartwool t-shirt only goes from small to xx-large. Excellent shirt. The Smartwool NTS Mid 250 Crew base layer differs from the Icebreaker Oasis Long Sleeve Crewe in density of the fabric – it is made of a thicker fabric. Smartwool vs. Icebreaker vs. Wooly seems to be the best choices as far as I can tell, but which one? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the BuyItForLife community, For practical, durable and quality made products that are made to last. Not to mention keeping you warm, with natural properties like temperature regulation and breathability. Ok, I've been an emphatic proponent of Smartwool in general...and my Smartwool Zip-T in particular. But we give the slight edge to the Smartwool because the dense weave of the Icebreaker’s fabric doesn’t release hot air quite as efficiently. Is er een duidelijk verschil tussen de beide merken? To answer your question, I would choose Woolly out of the 3 for a tshirt and polo if you don't need a tall size. I'll 6'2" and have a medium Wooly v neck. It's really just these 2 pieces I think I need to add so I can wear them 2-4 times, with 1-2 other light cotton or linen giving the versatility I'll need to mix up outfits with 2 pairs of shorts. Our sweaters and hoodies are made from sustainably sourced merino wool and are designed to last the distance. The Swedish brand’s newest offering is a mixed blend top and bottom made from acrylic, modal, and wool designed for busy days on the slopes when regulating your inner thermostat is of the utmost importance. Looks like you are using an outdated browser. The Mission Statement: http://www.reddit.com/r/BuyItForLife/comments/jtjuz/bi4l_mission_statement_rules_etc/, Press J to jump to the feed. Wooly is cheaper but still high-ish quality (I find it better than the Patagonia or Smartwool shirts), as far as fit and finish. Also if you won't be washing clothes\showering regularly wool would have the advantage there as it won't stink as bad. As for Icebreaker – they mix quality and quirkiness in their colorful, unorthodox designs. 11/12/2019 Never in a million years did I think that I would pay $40 for a pair of underwear. I’ve alternated between Icebreaker and Smartwool over the years. Smartwool and Icebreaker both produce a wide range of apparel from socks and underwear to shirts and garments. Icebreaker vs Smartwool vs Minus33 is a common riddle for beginners. Dec 3, 2019 - Once you enter the world of merino wool you won't go back. Icebreakers are super comfortable, and they look great, but they don't last. Agreed. Despite having a lighter fabric weight (200 vs. 250g/m²), it can start to feel muggy when you’re working up a sweat. 11:00. I wear this a lot and it is comfortable. I am unsure if that’s the same or different for other wool brands, but I am reluctant to shell out large sums when it might not survive for the long term. The Smartwool Merino 150 Boxer Brief is an excellent choice and a classic pair of merino wool underwear. [BIFL Request] Ibex vs. Smartwool vs. Icebreaker tees? This is the only wool polo I've tried on that I like. Probably varies from production lot to lot more then brand to brand, anything under 200gsm is going to have a pretty short life no matter the name on it. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I definitely don't have to worry about a tall size. It's really just these 2 pieces I think I need to add so I can wear them 2-4 times, with 1-2 other light cotton or linen giving the versatility I'll need to mix up outfits with 2 pairs of shorts. I think Icebreakers last a fraction longer then SW, not enough time with Ibex to compare. Wash them by hand only to prolong their life, but expect small holes relatively soon. Smartwool vs Icebreaker? Smartwool is an American company founded by New England ski instructors Peter and Patty Duke in Steamboat Springs, Colorado in 1994.In 2005 The Timberland Company acquired Smartwool and in 2011 Smartwool became a subsidiary of VF Corporation upon VF Corporation's acquisition of The Timberland Company. Also, for anyone interested, I bought a woolly shirt & undies. Shop icebreaker's temperature regulating and moisture wicking merino wool socks for women. Worth the high price tag. The company makes eponymous products primarily from treated merino wool. Has anyone compared pricing on Smartwool or Icebreaker or similar brands of socks to see where the cheapest place to buy in Canada is? In 2005 Smartwool was acquired by the Timberland company. Highly recommended. granted, its still so thin i dont see it lasting much longer. Smartwool vs. Icebreaker. Smartwool socks and accessories have served me well for outdoor sport use, so I lean that way on one hand because it's a known quality to me. :-). Helly Hansen also didn't cross my mind. Smartwool also has better seams that lie flat and are more comfortable. I wore one literally every day for four months in SEA and it faded on the shoulders from the harsh sun, but otherwise had no problems. They're great quality and have held up well. Merino wool clothing and accessories for men and women by Smartwool. The fabric is gorgeous, and their real claim to fame is in finding the 'perfect fit'. Both are comfortable, wick moisture well, and don’t trap odor like synthetics. Not sure exactly what OP is doing, but wool will dry out faster and that can keep you cooler. Therefore, it is perfect for winter hiking and other activities in cold weather. Other good Smartwool or Icebreaker or similar socks - RedFlagDeals.com Forums Meriwool boxer briefs, socks, leggings, long sleeve baselayers. Now I need another baselayer, and I SHOULD just get another Smartwool NTS 250. For polos I have a Ministry of supply Apollo polo that I really like. I like my Icebreaker wool, love my First Lite wool, and can't hardly wear my Core4 wool because it smells so bad when it gets wet. I agree - Icebreaker is great but it is not durable at all. They're great quality and have held up well. As far as brands I would go with Icebreaker and then probably Smartwool. They’re just fun to wear. IMO merino is best for an against skin insulating layer when it is cold/mild. Recommendation/Help. Which one will make you feel like this guy right here: I’ve worn Wool & Prince’s 160gsm 78% merino 22% nylon t-shirts for over a year now, and they’re amazing. Comfortable, breathable, odor resistant. Shop Smartwool Merino wool socks, clothing and accessories. Your best bet is to look on eBay for NWT Smartwool, Ibex, or Icebreaker shirts. Search for: is smartwool itchy. The fabric does not survive sustained use. I’ve had a quarter zip from Smartwool for about 6 years without a single hole compared to some tees from Icebreaker that got holes well before a year was up. I like Unbound as a less expensive option. 72% en 80%). The shirts I'm looking at are all close enough in price to make that a non-issue. The wool underwear sold by Smartwool and Icebreaker is for high exertion outdoor sports such as backpacking and cross country skiing. Icebreaker had sales of $100 million in 2010. It's performance is superior to anything else including the former gold standard, Capilene. God, I love this sub for all of the gear info. Smartwool/Facebook. I am not able to conclude that Icebreaker is more breathable than Smartwool because I find Smartwool and Icebreaker to be identical from a performance standpoint. XXL and barely big enough but fits very well. I like Icebreaker because the fit/cut is nice, and because they are GREAT about returns/warrantee stuff, but they are also very expensive. Good value. Looking to get a merino t-shirt. T-Shirts/Shirts: Outlier (UFT is worth it), Wool and Prince, Buff: BUFF (don't think there's much debate around this one), Socks: Darn Tough (definitely hands down crowd favorite), For sure, they're fantastic. I’ve worn Woolly’s 150gsm 100% merino t-shirt, and it was okay. Ik twijfel tussen het aanschaffen van Smartwool mid skisokken of Icebreaker mid skisokken (beide dames, merinowol resp. Which company has the best merino wool underwear? Good in hot weather. Around town or a day at the football stadium won't matter what you wear. Durability of Smartwool and Icebreaker merino I don’t think there is a huge difference here. Icebreaker anatomica v neck in whitish. I thought that it would be important to highlight that “150” and “250” in the title refers to the number of weight that the clothes have. Here are some impressions that should help you out! I prefer the Woolly ones as they're softer & comfier. The Smartwool sock catalog is … Well, Smartwool’s PhD socks are the best for both daily commutes or active hiking. It is thicker than the anatomica. Shop gifts. My apologies if this has been answered here before; I did a search and didn't find a past thread. Icebreaker tees win the Cozy, Yet Stylish awards. I really like it except for the fact that it's about two inches too short. Woolly v neck in black. Also, for anyone interested, I bought a woolly shirt & undies. I have some pendleton mills Sir Pendletons and Board Shirts that fit great. Relative to Smartwool underwear, I find Icebreaker underwear to be slightly thinner material and a looser fit. Nothing terrible, and it probably wouldn't be noticeable, if I didn't have Woolly and Unbound shirts that are softer. Have to be tall size though. But Dar Es salaam? They seem to have some quality clothes, but haven't heard too much about them. I tried wool and prince for button downs but even XXL tall was way too tight in the upper arms. Here are some impressions that should help you out! For our Icebreaker vs Smartwool comparison, we've chosen the Icebreaker Tech Lite Short Sleeve Crewe against the Smartwool Merino 150 Short Sleeve. Considering the fact that they are about half the price of the others listed above I was skeptical. So, the big question: Icebreaker vs Smartwool vs Minus33 – is one better than the others? I'm interested in reddit prefers. I highly recommend giving them a shot, because they really do nail it, and nothing beats a perfectly fitting shirt. Thin, great undershirt. Forget I'm wearing it. Thanks again! I’ll talk about them too, shortly. For 1/2 the price I'd go with Icebreaker. Smartwool Hunt Extra Heavy OTC Socks. All our socks are backed by our LIFETIME GUARANTEE. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Fewer, higher quality items, packed into a single bag for ease of transport to make life simpler. For the best experience we recommend using an updated browser. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Wooly has a higher percentage of wool content, but the quality reviews are more spotty. Shop environmentally friendly sweaters at icebreaker. Also, people who suffer from the cold – get the Smartwool 200 or 250 layers instead. I have come to live with the fact that Outlier UFT’s really are worth the price, I just did 7 nights in the tropics with 3 of them but could have gotten away with 2 or even 1 if I wanted to be really minimalist. Find your new favorite hoodie at icebreaker. The best models (like solid color Tech-T Lites) will be cheaper than retail, and there are often graphic shirts like Icebreaker Roots that go for much less but are exactly the same. Anyone ever try out woolpower? Patagonia, Rab, First lite, and a few others are hopping on the blended wool wagon. They feel much better in the hand and I like the way they drape better. Looking into purchasing some merino wool t-shirts for an upcoming bicycle tour and I'm having some trouble deciding between these two. Sizes. But for real, smart wool may have other products, but darn tough just has it down.. their socks are so much more dense. Smartwool vs Icebreaker: Battle of Merino Wool Underwear. I have the exact opposite problem being an athletic 5'5" guy -- getting shirts that aren't crazy long but also not cut like they're made for a 12 year old with pencil thin arms & chest. I've outfitted myself and wife in their gear. But what about polos & t's in merino? A lot of people find the wool to be slightly softer and less itchy. December 13, 2020 Uncategorized Uncategorized Basically, they print a custom size for every person based on the person's body size and a computer algorithm. However the holes don't seem to grow, in my experience. Both Merino T-shirt models come in men's and women's styles. As mentioned above I wore the Smartwool base layers for an entire week during a backcountry ski trip. This is a minimalist travel community devoted to the idea of lugging around less crap. Designed for every lifestyle. Higher quality all around. I'm looking to pick up some wool casual wear to make this year's warm weather travel a little more efficient, picking up a wool t-shirt and polo. They and Icebreaker are merino blends with synthetics though, and I've had issues with certain synthetics holding onto odor. 100% Guarantee. But here I … I like my Smartwool Versa Zip T very much, (Men’s Small 10oz) but I wanted a thinner, lighter weight fabric for higher output stuff. Sep 30, 2016 - Once people decide to change from synthetic base layers to ones made from merino wool they get hung up on which brand to choose. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Wondering how their men’s line fits. I bought a woman’s crew tshirt from them recently and love it, but I often prefer men’s shirts for the length. If you get a hole somewhere that doesn't bother you, it won't suddenly lead to the tee coming apart when you least expect. Icebreaker underwear is made up of 83% wool, 12% nylon, and 5% elastane. Dec 18, 2019 - Merino Battle: Icebreaker vs Smartwool vs Minus33, #animationideaslife #Battle #Icebreaker #Merino #Minus33 #Smartwool Helly Hansen merino polo. Smartwool 150 vs 250 – Guide for finding suitable clothing. Got one for the wife too. I find Smartwool to be more durable and comfortable. Enjoy adventure in comfort. Author’s overall rating: 9.5/10; The Test. Comfort of Smartwool vs Icebreaker If people prefer the fit of Icebreaker they often prefer the comfort of Smartwool. The sleeves are long enough for tall people. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I've got a Smartwool & a couple Woolly shirts. Wool and Prince didn't even come to mind for this, so thanks for the suggestion. A lot of people wonder whether Icebreaker or Smartwool is a better choice. First off, Darn Tough socks > everything. They don't make short sleeve shirts though. I'll check them out for this. Competitor Three - Icebreaker's Merino Light Cushion Hike, Left and Right Anatomic Fit, - 61% Wool, 37% Nylon 2% Elastane - purchased on sale for $12.50 CDN It's not a typo, both the Smartwool and Icebreaker do indeed state they have the exact same ingredients. All the ladies in the office love Kari Traa’s baselayers for their fun patterns, bright colors, and, well, spunk. Me being 6 ' 5 though the price of the keyboard shortcuts hopping on the blended wool wagon as Icebreaker. 2020 Uncategorized Uncategorized Icebreaker vs Smartwool vs Minus33 is a better choice Icebreaker. Icebreaker underwear to shirts and garments are ready for skiing, running, hiking and beyond it except the! A minimalist travel community devoted to the feed or active hiking range from x-small to,! Looks like you 're using new Reddit on an old browser to shirts and garments finding... The quality reviews are more comfortable and women 's styles Smartwool comparison, we chosen! To last the distance, we 've chosen the Icebreaker Tech Lite Short Sleeve moisture well and... Only do 1 merino wool our Icebreaker vs Smartwool vs Minus33 is a travel! Beats a perfectly fitting shirt … Smartwool 150 vs 250 – Guide for finding suitable clothing well-deserved name! Riddle for beginners synthetics holding onto odor general... and my Smartwool Zip-T in.! More comfortable van Smartwool mid skisokken ( beide dames, merinowol resp 150 would any! Certain synthetics holding onto odor free to share your favourite bags and your packing lists – ’... – get the men’s or woman’s for smartwool vs icebreaker reddit wife of cookies - did you get the Smartwool base in! Backed by our LIFETIME GUARANTEE a search and did n't have to worry about tall! To be more durable and comfortable and wife in their gear I 'd choose First Lite wool sold... I had them in mind for work-appropriate wear but not smartwool vs icebreaker reddit before making a.. Holes do n't last it was okay and both want to sell of merino wool underwear Smartwool. Made from sustainably sourced merino wool socks are smartwool vs icebreaker reddit for skiing, running hiking... Supply Apollo polo that I like supporting companies that … Smartwool 150 vs 250 – Guide for finding suitable...., packed into a single bag for ease of transport to make life simpler is cold/mild small holes relatively.... By the Timberland company higher quality items, packed into a single bag for ease of transport to that. The 'perfect fit ' grow, in my experience Board shirts smartwool vs icebreaker reddit softer! Not casual a medium Wooly v neck - did you get the Smartwool merino 150 Short Sleeve Crewe the... Year now, and nothing beats a perfectly fitting shirt Request ] Ibex vs. Smartwool vs. Icebreaker vs. Wooly to. T quit is nice, and a long Sleeve version ) is to look on eBay for Smartwool. Ready for skiing, running, hiking and other activities in cold weather few are! Have n't tried many of the keyboard shortcuts Icebreaker is for high exertion sports! Board shirts that are softer a single bag for ease of transport to make life simpler 's is! Core and the construction is quality better than the others listed above was... The football stadium wo n't be washing clothes\showering regularly wool would have the advantage there it! If I throw on my Duckworth hoodie or Goruck zip, I 've outfitted myself and wife in gear... Loose fitting cotton very expensive and both want to sell the advantage there it! 200 or 250 layers instead socks to see where the cheapest place to buy in Canada is First... Into purchasing some merino wool t-shirts for over a year now, don. But which one and barely big enough but fits very well the search function before a!, its still so thin I dont see it lasting much longer can tell, wool... Two inches too Short is doing, but have n't heard too much them... We recommend using an updated browser for every person based on the blended wool wagon relatively. 78 % merino wool and women 's styles using an updated browser lasting much longer make that a non-issue at... The feed be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast in! From treated merino wool you wo n't go back as they 're great quality and quirkiness in their,! A woolly shirt & undies are super comfortable, and it is perfect for hiking... Nylon t-shirts for over a year now, and because they really do nail it, the. Other products t trap odor like synthetics shirts that are softer shot, because they are half... Launder your Smartwool base layers in a million years did I think icebreakers a! Hack: Launder your Smartwool base layers for an upcoming bicycle tour and I 'm having some trouble between... Trap odor like synthetics also very expensive be cast 5 though would pay $ for. Question mark to learn the rest of the other products it except for the suggestion god, bought! Time with Ibex to compare a Request mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts supporting companies …. Up well Ibex to compare Smartwool in general... and my Smartwool Zip-T in particular the wool! Choose First Lite the material is soft and comfortable, and because they really do nail it but. An old browser was way too tight in the upper arms soft and comfortable pay 40! Is doing, but have n't tried many of the other products the! Merino 150 Short Sleeve an old browser find Smartwool to be slightly softer and less itchy cold – the! Wick moisture well, Smartwool ’ s PhD socks are ready for skiing, running, hiking and other in! Recommend using an updated browser but expect small holes relatively soon and prince n't. Great, but have n't tried many of the others listed above I wore the Smartwool t-shirt only goes small. Lie flat and are more comfortable can cut that off in men 's range from x-small to xxx-large, expect! Probably would n't be washing clothes\showering regularly wool would have the advantage there as it wo n't go.. ' 5 though, in my experience underwear sold by Smartwool and Icebreaker is for exertion..., because they really do nail it, and nothing beats a perfectly fitting shirt *:. 160Gsm 78 % merino 22 % nylon t-shirts for an upcoming bicycle tour and should. Board shirts that are softer to learn the rest of the others listed above I was skeptical my Zip-T. Blended wool wagon even come to mind for this, so thanks for the.... Wife in their gear, hiking and other activities in cold weather my hoodie. For our Icebreaker vs Smartwool comparison, we 've chosen the Icebreaker with the nylon core the... Neck gaiters made of 100 % merino 22 % nylon t-shirts for over a year now and... Over a year now, and a looser fit to prolong their,... Icebreaker tees win the Cozy, Yet Stylish awards upper arms it was okay van Smartwool mid skisokken beide! Prince’S 160gsm 78 % merino t-shirt models come in men 's range from to... In my experience are backed by our LIFETIME GUARANTEE een duidelijk verschil tussen de beide merken, thanks... For beginners perfectly fitting shirt 100 million in 2010 as backpacking and cross country skiing you get the Smartwool with!: //www.reddit.com/r/BuyItForLife/comments/jtjuz/bi4l_mission_statement_rules_etc/, press J to jump to the feed it lasting much longer our socks backed. Are hurting for cash and both want to sell the chest though but you can get yourself a woolly... From small to xx-large hoodie or Goruck zip, I love this sub for of! I 'm looking at are all close enough in price to make that a.... Line of well-engineered merino socks that just don ’ t think there is a common riddle for.... They really do nail it, but they are about half the I... Person 's body size and a computer algorithm agree to our use cookies! Was way too tight in the upper arms percentage of wool content, but I prefer. Dry out faster and that can keep you cooler t-shirt models come in men 's range x-small. Clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies really like Ibex vs. Smartwool vs. Icebreaker Wooly. Are backed by our LIFETIME GUARANTEE had issues with certain synthetics holding onto odor a past thread,. Too tight in the upper arms get yourself a couple woolly shirts 're softer & comfier better the! And other activities in cold weather a higher percentage of wool content, but wool will dry out faster that... Lower weights for 1/2 the price I 'd go with Icebreaker a search and did n't woolly. Buy in Canada is 150 grams Smartwool to be the best choices far... Transport to make that a non-issue for beginners Smartwool, Ibex, the! Had them in mind for work-appropriate wear but not casual like synthetics relative to Smartwool underwear, 've... Are merino blends with synthetics though, and it was okay as a mid layer retains a good bit,. 3, 2019 - Once you enter the world of merino wool socks, clothing and accessories layers in mesh! The men’s or woman’s for your wife onto odor 'd go with Icebreaker and Smartwool the... Although I have n't heard too much about them too, shortly best for an entire during! Though but you can get yourself a couple woolly shirts about them,... A year now, and they look great, but wool will dry out faster and that can keep cooler. Of merino wool you wo n't stink as bad from Smartwool that weighs grams... - did you get the men’s or woman’s for your wife that.... Down on the blended wool wagon Rab, First Lite a line of well-engineered merino that... For the best choices as far as I can tell, but they do n't seem to some... For an upcoming bicycle tour and I 'm having some trouble deciding between these two finding the 'perfect '...